Why M&A Deals Fail
Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) are complex processes with high stakes.
Notable examples of such ventures not living up to expectations include the 2015 merger between Kraft, Heinz, and 3G Capital, which saw a dramatic halving of its share value…
Verizon's acquisition of Yahoo in 2017 and its prior purchase of AOL, both of which led to substantial financial write-downs…
And Bayer's 2016 acquisition of Monsanto, the maker of Round-Up, now embroiled in legal battles over claims linking its product to cancer!
Additionally, some anticipated deals have completely dissolved, such as the failed $24 billion merger between Rite Aid and Albertsons.
Despite thorough due diligence, many deals fail to achieve their outcomes.
Here are the primary reasons for these failures:
Misvaluation: Companies may be overvalued or undervalued due to an overemphasis on financials, neglecting other critical factors like market position or technology.
Poor integration process: Failing to properly integrate the acquired company can lead to operational disruptions, employee dissatisfaction, and loss of value. Moreover, underestimating the impact of cultural differences can lead to internal conflicts, affecting morale and productivity.
Negotiation errors: Overpaying for an acquisition or failing to negotiate favorable terms can lead to financial strain and regret.
External factors: Unforeseen external events, such as economic downturns or regulatory changes, can adversely affect the success of the deal.
Failure to assess alternatives and mitigate ris: Not considering alternative strategies for growth or exit can lead to missed opportunities and suboptimal outcomes.
Emotional attachment: if a Seller has a business that has been in the family for generations, this can lead to an inability to let go… This type of Seller may even look for reasons to kill the deal and may not even recognize they are doing it.
Inexperienced lawyers: don’t get me wrong, attorneys are great, but not having an experienced intelligence and strategic consultant is an issue in a lot of deals. There are deal focused attorneys and attorneys who are afraid to close a deal because they believe there should be no risk for their client. So having a solid team with the right lawyer and strategic consultant can make a big difference in getting a deal done.
How Strategic Intelligence Can Aid M&A Success
Strategic intelligence plays a pivotal role in navigating the complexities of M&A deals, offering solutions to the challenges outlined above. At every step of the process from A to Z basically.
Step 1: Identify the right opportunity
Using intelligence to identify market trends, key players, and acquisition opportunities is a must. It helps in identifying and screening potential targets based on strategic fit, growth potential, and compatibility, reducing the risk of misvaluation.
Step 2: Risk Assessment
Analyzing the risks associated with a potential target, including financial, operational, and reputation risks. Here, the lawyer plays its part with the legal due diligennce, contract reviews etc but the strategic consultant will consider the big picture: reputation, world events, market, last techs etc. It’s an extremely comprehensive type of research to insure success.
Beyond financial analysis, strategic intelligence provides insights into the target company's market position, reputation, technological assets, and cultural dynamics, ensuring a more accurate valuation and alignment of objectives.
An intelligence expert will help you minimize the risks associated with M&A operations through thorough analysis and enhanced due diligence. It will also help anticipate various type of scenarios for the future and give a clear line on the next steps, the risks to consider, anticipate potential costs and how to prevent them.
Step 3: Support in Negotiation
Providing strategic information to support negotiations, such as the strengths and weaknesses of the target, and stakeholder expectations is also something that can be done with our… spy techniques !
Armed with comprehensive market and competitive intelligence, companies can negotiate from a position of strength, securing better terms and avoiding overpayment.
With the help of an expert you can analyze too - during the course of a physical negotiation - if your future associate is trying to hide something, an objection, a lie (through reading his micro-expressions and body language). You can read his real intentions, you can adapt. You can profile his type of personality, understand who you’ll have to deal (hopefully for the rest of your life if the M&A goes well…) now - you’d rather know if he’s a “pain in the ass” type of colleague, or a real fit with your personality etc.
Step 4: Integration Planning
Preparing for post-acquisition integration by analyzing cultural and operational compatibility is the step that is mostly neglected… And it is the most difficult part. The operational integration of the deal is complex.
An intelligent expert will give you here a competitive advantage by ensuring that resources are allocated efficiently by identifying the best targets and avoiding poor investments, providing insights into the culture and processes of the target company.
It supports ongoing market monitoring and competitive analysis, helping to adjust strategies as needed and ensuring the long-term success of the deal.
Conclusion
By offering deep market insights and competitive analysis, strategic intelligence empowers owners to take a more active and informed role in the deal, complementing the advisory work rather than being dependent on it.
As I always say, we’re here to help and support he decision-making process by making it efficient. We provide insights into alternative growth strategies, potential market developments, and the competitive landscape, ensuring that M&A is the best course of action. It allows the stakeholders to be in the KNOWN and take decisions not based on gutts or the simple due diligence led by the M&A lawyer, but with a tremendous set of tools that bring important value for the future.
Comments